Cowling exit lip

Nev

Quick-build 4-place B #25
I had a nice “win” today when looking to make a cowling exit lip. After trimming the Vans air intake, I was about to throw the trimmed fibreglass away. The shape of it seemed pretty close to what I wanted for the cowl lip. 5 minutes with the angle grinder later and I have what I think should be an effective cowl exit lip.

This got me thinking. Would there be any merit in mounting the lip on a hinge so it can retract inside the cowl ? Similar to a cowl flap, but less complex. It may create a small amount of turbulence inside the cowl, but probably less than on the outside.

Click image for larger version  Name:	C0EE91A1-854C-4D21-B5B1-0DA3CA1E75BC.jpeg Views:	0 Size:	258.4 KB ID:	65012
 
Fly it like it is, then decide, but I suspect you will need at least that much cowl lip all of the time to avoid cooling issues.
 
Is the cowling lip big enough?

How much outlet area should I be aiming for ?
 
It looks big enough Nev. You want about a 30 degree difference between the line of the cowl bottom and the lip angle to create the best low pressure - according to Bob. Mark
 
And often builders have to open up the cowl bottom air outlet to increase the exit area for better cooling. Just consider that possibility when you think about how to attach the lip. Mark
 
Airspeed is the single biggest factor in cooling a Bearhawk of standard design.

Prolonged slow flight with part power, or full power, results in heating up the engine to undesirable levels, normally the oil overheats. Sustained climb at full power - forget about it. I have to keep it lean of peak to prevent CHTs going through the roof.

On the other hand, in winter, I struggle to keep the engine hot enough when running LOP. I leave cowl flaps shut and it still won't warm up.

I think I am more concerned with engine temps because I have them under my control. Most guys I fly with don't pay close attention to them.

I assume cowl flaps are slightly less efficient than than a lip, however, I need about 130 to 140 square inches.
With the flaps shut, I have something like 90 or 80 sq.in exit area, with no lip (no suction).
These numbers changed since I posted them years ago, as we rebuilt the cowl and enlarged the flaps.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Jon and Mark. I think I’ll aim for around 120 sq inches. I assume that with the lip it should equate to more “virtual” area. That should get me underway for test flying and I can then adjust it from there.
 
Prolonged slow flight with part power, or full power, results in heating up the engine to undesirable levels, normally the oil overheats

Regarding the oil cooler, obviously there’s a number of contributing factors. But how much of a factor do you think the physical location of the oil cooler is ? For instance having mine mounted on the lower firewall I wonder if the outflow from the oil cooler is going to “clash” with the out-flowing cylinder cooling air rather than having a smooth flow of both.
 
There is a ratio that is "recommended" of inlet air area to outlet area I want to say (but am not sure) that it is 1.5 outlet area to 1 inlet area. Tony Bingelis gives this ratio in one of his books.

Nev, observing how your cooling system works is one of the more important things during your test flying the plane. Just be aware that many builders have had to go back and increase exit area after flying. Myself included. On most all my planes. To improve cooling. Mark
 
Where are we basing the opening measurement? Is it firewall forward / tunnel forward? Or is the tunnel area also included in the total square inches?
 
I have a few "practice" oil cooler plenums. I am thinking of using one of them on the cooler exit, and use scat tube to dump that air outside the cowling side. To me, just dumping it in the lower cowl amounts to a leak from inside the baffles to the lower cowl. Might help both oil cooling and engine cooling.
 
In his blue book he says "Ordinarily most builders provide a slightly larger area (about 10 per cent larger) for the air outlet than for the inlet opening."
In the paragraph immediately before he also states "Some builders and manufacturers (also in desperation) resort to the installation of a large, deflection lip along the bottom opening in an effort to create a sort of venturi-like low pressure area to improve the airflow through the engine cowling. If you have to depend upon this double-ugly solution, you should probably restudy your cowling and cooling installation and rework it."
I'm guessing some of Tony's general cowling advice doesn't necessarily apply directly to the BH?
 
I think my oil cooler is mounted in the same locations as yours Nev. My oil temps have been perfect at 175 to 180 F degrees.
 
At right angles to the direction of airflow (normal to the flow), include all open areas where air exits the cowl.
 
Last edited:
Regarding the oil cooler, obviously there’s a number of contributing factors. But how much of a factor do you think the physical location of the oil cooler is ? For instance having mine mounted on the lower firewall I wonder if the outflow from the oil cooler is going to “clash” with the out-flowing cylinder cooling air rather than having a smooth flow of both.

The main thing is the supply of cold air to the front of the cooler, heat transfer is more efficient when the air is moving more slowly through the cooler, so the air has time to heat up and remove the heat.

Because of the drag through the cooling fins (engine or cooler), you need a larger cowl exit area to help suck the air out. The pressure on the inlet side isn't enough, on it's own. Hence 1:1.5 ratio. There should be an oversupply of air to the front side of the cooling fins. A pressure bubble, in other words. This is why cowls lift upwards in flight, relative to the engine. Of course a plenum solves that issue.

I have a 3" inlet SCAT to my 12 pass cooler. It is not enough. Once up a time, I had the whole frontal area of the oil cooler exposed to the oncoming airflow, that was ideal - the oil ran very cool.

Another consideration, the longer the tube into the cooler, and the more bends in the tube - the greater the loses. You can use SKEET to improve this. My tube is about 12" long, with a 90 degree bend.

Opening my cowl flaps makes a considerable difference to oil temperature, so I assume that suction on the outlet side of the cooler is all that's required. The cowl flaps create so much suction, that part of the top cowl pops inside out when I open them fully (standard design for top cowl).
 
Last edited:
Since I’m running a different engine my info doesn’t apply for the most part. I just wanted to say that I personally agree with Tony and think the cowl lip is a rudimentary fix. However, lots of manufacturers have and still are using it. I was unwilling to put a lip on my Luscombe and felt the same about my BH.

The Continental IO360 is known for being hard to cool; an unfair reputation IMO. I have 80sqin of cowl exit area at the tunnel and a significant portion of that is blocked by my muffler. I forgot to measure my cowl flaps but they probably double the outlet area. During the summer I need to leave my cowl flaps partially open most of the time, unless I’m above 10k ft, and with them fully open I can climb unrestricted. During the winter I can fly with the flaps closed and the engine at nice warm temperatures.

All this oil cooler placement and ducting mumbo jumbo…shoulda used a Continental. 😉
 
I would be tempted to try it with out the lip first. A friend took one off his Murphy and it went about 4mph faster. We have a Continental IO-360 that runs cool with no cowl lip. There is even a pc of cardboard on the oil cooler in summer. So far there have been no cooling issues and our mechanic says we have very efficient cooling. We made aluminum baffles that fit tight around the engine. There is about a 2-3" rubber gap seals on the baffles that are bent slightly inward with the cowl and nosebowl on to seal the top of the engine off. If you can get the nose bowl as close to the spinner as reasonable. I think the space between our spinner and nose bowl is 3/8" max. When I was reading up on pressure cowls, LO-Presti's, James engineering etc a big topic was sealing the engine in and trying to minimize the air drawn out by the spinner. It has been a while but I believe it was as high as 20% of the air in the inlets can be drawn out by the prop. The Continental IO360 has the fuel system on top that does not make a true pressure cowl so we sealed the top of the engine tight to the cowl and nose bowl to emulate a pressure cowl. The advantage of a pressure cowl is if the space over the engine is pressurized that puts the air through the cylinders efficiently. If it is possible to seal between the engine and nose bowl around the prop opening that is a bonus. Then look at the configuration under the engine and try to make it as clean as possible to duct the air out. We used a custom 3 into 1 exhaust headers that run parallel to the engine that left the underside wide open to take the air out efficiently.

For the nosebowl I had to custom form a nose bowl so I fiberglassed a thin duct half into the top half of the nose bowl and made removable aluminum bottom duct halves. The aluminum duct bottom and fiberglass duct half was intended to form a duct to project air up into the cavity over the engine so it did not stumble over the front of the engine. The front cylinders were too cold so we took out the aluminum bottom duct halves so now the cylinders are fairly uniform for cooling. My partner wanted to put cooling vents in but I did not want to do fixes for issues if none was required. The more efficient the cooling the less drag the cooling creates. Everything I read was the inlet openings are two big. I started with the MC3a nosebowl and made a custom lower half to work with our Continental. While I was at it I took and vertical inch out of both inlets. Main reason was to protect the fuel pump and lines inside the nose bowl. The downsized inlets did no harm.

I used to subscribe to Kitplanes and they always had great articles. One of the biggest issues for homebuilders is cooling. I was on other forums reading about builders struggles so I tried to incorporate as much as possible into cooling during the build as possible. There were a lot of good information on the Web by Zavaston on cooling his racing Lancair. My research started with the attached article from Kitplanes. The information is Lycoming based but we put our own spin on it for the Continental as a pressure cowl with fuel & air induction on top a maintenance headache.

Schmidbauer wrote book(s) on how he got his Mustang flying at 262mph and he likely has gone past that as I quit following a long time ago. There is a lot of valuable information there. I used to be on the James aircraft forums for the pressure cowl information.

I scanned Zavaston's Kitplane article on cooling and pressure cowls. He is an engineer and did an amazing amount of research. This is the condensed version of his his cooling results. This is a good read and with any luck his information may still be hanging out on the web. Best advice I can give is learn as much as you can on the subject and the results may be surprising. Hope this is of some value to you.
Glenn
 

Attachments

Last edited:
This is a follow up to my comment on cooling. The Continental IO360 threw a few challenges like the engine mount, fuel system return and the nose bowl. Bob Barrows gave us the tube sizes and layout to modify the engine bed mount for a Cessna 337 Skymaster to the BH 4 place. We were able to get a bed mount for $100 that needed some repairs. One partner was a certified welder so no issues with getting the bed mount. One photo shows the modifications to the top half of the nose bowl to fit over the engine. I sectioned across the top and raised it an inch and glassed that squiggle. I cut the inside of each bowl inlet and moved them outward an inch and glassed the gaps in. That got the fuel pump and fuel lines tucked in behind the nose bowl. It also got the inlets so no inlet was behind the spinner blocking off that space to have the nose clean at the spinner. The white gelcoat gives an indication of how modified that half was. I used the bottom half to make a mould. I made an outline of what the lower nose bowl needed to be to fit over the end of the bed mount on plywood. I used Bondo on the lower half to sculpt the shape & templated left to right for symmetry. When I was happy then I used paste wax for mould release and laid fiberglass over the lower bowl to make a stiffened female mould. Waxed the female mould and built the lower half with fiberglass and West epoxy. The top and bottom were cut to mate up. The Continental IO360 made some challenges but in the end allowed a very clean firewall forward cowl & nose that made over coming the unique engine worth the effort.
 

Attachments

  • BH727 11.JPG
    BH727 11.JPG
    1.9 MB · Views: 1
  • BH727 1.JPG
    BH727 1.JPG
    173.2 KB · Views: 1
  • IMG-20140501-00059.jpg
    IMG-20140501-00059.jpg
    227.4 KB · Views: 1
Here are a couple good Kitplane articles on cooling. The third photo in the first article is one that most builders could build. It shows how the cooling baffles will seal against the upper cowl to retain the cooling air pressure over the engine. https://www.kitplanes.com/engine-theory-engine-cooling-avoiding-meltdown/

All the articles that I read on cooling is to seal the top baffles and fill in anywhere air can escape. Air that escapes the baffling is tramp air that is going to increase the air volume trying to exit the cooling to exit the cowl. The ideal is all the air goes through the engine with no leakage. The emphasis in all the articles is sealing the top of the engine to eliminate any leakage.

https://www.kitplanes.com/firewall-forward-cowls-baffles-and-intake-air/
 
Be carful adding a lip, it may disrupt the airflow enough that you lose the airflow and venturi effect on the cowl exit and actually lose cooling. That's a comment I've heard from a few guys flying Murphy's on floats, where cooling is a huge issue.
 
Some of Murphy’s products were being constructed with a high speed engine cowl which didn’t provide a decent inlet/outlet ratio at lower speeds when fitted with floats. Builders with a MC-3 cowl and a tight baffle had good results. I did with the one I built with low 300’s cylinder temps and solid 180 oil temps. The high speed cowl shouldn’t have been used on any of Murphy’s aircraft on floats. A lot of builders tried re inventing the wheel when it came to their cooling dilemmas and most didn’t solve the problem.
 
Agreed the racing cowl is not good for a Bearhawk but there are principles that apply to all cooling. That is exactly what we did. Modified the MC-3A to work with our engine, went to the nth degree to get the baffles sealed to the engine to prevent air leakage to maintain pressure. The cowl at the cooling outlet is in the same line as the rest of the cowl. It may be that having the cowl extend over the tunnel helps with increasing the depth of the outlet. We also put the aluminum tear drop profile around the air exit on the firewall corners. The rounded corners make for more a laminar flow of the exit air. Sharp edges at the firewall exit creates turbulence that impedes air flow. The exhaust pipes are close to the outside to leave the centre wide open for air outlet. It does makes no sense to put a racing cowl on a Bearhawk. Use the best principles for cooling by retaining pressure over the engine, rounded firewall outlet etc... We have a clean cowl underside so the air from the prop may help with inducing exhaust air flow. We had to make the inlet flow less efficient to get good uniform temperatures across all cylinders. It may be that the Continental IO360 configuration allowed for the efficient cooling with the way the cowl was constructed or just out right good luck.
 
Last edited:
I want unrestricted climb and I'm willing to give up some speed for it. Constantly monitoring cylinder head temps and flying the airplane according to what they say doesn't really excite me much.

I looked at the MC-3A and the price and fabwork don't phase me a bit, but it's really ugly. I was thinking about using a Stinson 108 nosebowl on my bearhawk. The inlets seem a bit bigger, and the chin is slightly longer which will give me more space to put in horizontal fuel injection. I even know where to order a CF variant.

Any thoughts on some other nosebowl that won't have CHT limitations? I see so many bearhawks with all kinds of cooling mods on them and I'd rather skip past that and put on a different nose bowl, have a generous outlet, tight baffling and be done with it.
 
I was reading about checking and setting the minimum fuel flow from the fuel servo. Apparently this makes quite a difference to the CHT on extended climbs. Effectively it means making sure that it’s running sufficiently rich to cool the cylinders, without being too rich such that the engine falters. Then it can be leaned according to preference.
 
Any thoughts on some other nosebowl that won't have CHT limitations? I see so many bearhawks with all kinds of cooling mods on them and I'd rather skip past that and put on a different nose bowl, have a generous outlet, tight baffling and be done with it.

All theory I've read (Nasa studies) says treat the Exit size as a cooling throttle. So that plus the tightness of the baffling primarily controls the CHT. Nosebowls not so much, but a poor design will not flow well.

I will echo and validate what Glenn and another Patrol Builder advised me... A bottom cowl that has some extra room at the exit tunnel for airflow out of the cowl had sufficient cooling with no lip. The Patrol was based in the south. I wish I had some dimensions. Lycoming wants a pressure differential of 5" of water across the cylinders. Measuring the pressure drop is pretty simple, tools are fairly inexpensive, and it seems that very few do it.

Glenn, what is the measurement of the opening between the top of the tunnel and the bottom cowl in your Four Place?
 
Last edited:
From what I've been able to gather, speed affects inlet pressure, cowl inlet size affects available air (which there is plenty), outlet size affects the restriction unto the point of having negative pressure (negative restriction), the position of the inlets affect how much of the air comes from dynamic air pressure and how much of it comes from the prop. The current design has very little inlet in front of the prop, most of the inlet is behind the root where there isn't any prop twist. I think a cowl that moves the inlet to the outside edges will probably work better as it can take advantage of the prop induced pressure instead of just the dynamic pressure of whatever speed you are going.

Also, patrol data isn't very useful for us 4 place guys as we have another row of cylinders to cool, and we really aren't going much faster, especially with bushwheels.
 
That is an interesting perspective, however it would depend entirely on the design of the lip - as with all things aerodynamic, shape is all important.
 
The current design has very little inlet in front of the prop, most of the inlet is behind the root where there isn't any prop twist. I think a cowl that moves the inlet to the outside edges will probably work better as it can take advantage of the prop induced pressure instead of just the dynamic pressure of whatever speed you are going.

That is not resonating with me from an engineering perspective, if you are using carbon prop - they have a much better shape factor near the root. Metal prop - I would tend to agree that a different cowl could possibly improve things...

Still, I would assume the prop is creating lower air pressure in the cowl at low airspeeds - it's just not possible in a free stream to create very high pressure in the cowl without good airspeed.

I can climb unrestricted in our plane, but only if I am prepared to accept higher engine times, well within the design limits, but above my personal limits.
Cylinder head temps stabilise at about 210*C (410*F) on the hottest cylinder during a max power climb on a cold day (near freezing), on a hot day (30*C / 86*F) the engine gets much hotter in a full power climb e.g. 215*C (420*F) which is getting too close to the manufacturer redline for my personal comfort 240*C (460*F). This is cowl flaps open in all cases.
 
A lot of the stuff I have read seems to be applicable to higher speed aircraft where ram air can be significant for delta P, just like Jonathon said above. I am not sure how well it applies to our application. The only non-stock thing I am going to do is have a exit ramp from the lower engine mount to the lip of the tunnel. A couple of RV guys claim it knocked 40 degrees off their CHT's. For me it also acts as a radiant heat shield for the EFI fuel pumps, which I mounted low on the north side of the firewall.

I bought enough Ti for the firewall and tunnel, but ended up using the SS tunnel so I could use the Ti for the ramp/heat shield.
 
The RV guys is where I got most of this information: https://vansairforce.net/community/showthread.php?t=196881
https://vansairforce.net/community/showthread.php?t=196881 Post 6 says a lot.

Also, have pictures of a Bearhawk with Hartzell 3 blade trailblazer. With the stock nose bowl, very little of the actual blade crosses the inlet, it's all root. In my case, I have the standard Hartzell 2 blade metal prop. I plan on opening my cowling up a little bit.

As far as unrestricted climb, I desire less than 400F while climbing full power at Vy on a standard day. The cessna 180's I've been around have no trouble with this, I want the same from my BH and I'm willing to engineer to get there.

Given the number of people with a lip, huge cowl flaps, louvers, and everything else, I think it may be easier to just start with or modify the nose bowl to move the inlet 2-3" further to the top/side to collect some of that prop induced pressure.
 
If you look at certified airplanes with cowls that have been designed in the last 20 years, you'll notice they put a pretty big emphasis of laminar flow of the inlet air. Big square holes don't do that. I'd probably start with that in mind if you were making your own cowl, or looking for one to adapt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nev
If you look at certified airplanes with cowls that have been designed in the last 20 years, you'll notice they put a pretty big emphasis of laminar flow of the inlet air. Big square holes don't do that. I'd probably start with that in mind if you were making your own cowl, or looking for one to adapt.

Can you shoot me some examples of cowls that have this?
 
Mooney Acclaim, Cirrus, even the Carbon Cub to an extent. I can’t find the info I collected last year when I was thinking about a nosebowl change but the gist was to place the inlets as far part and high as possible with smooth transitions.

Done right and the engine runs significantly cooler and the reduced cooling drag can result in a nice speed increase.
 
"Not great for the climb ....." .Too true! - don't try LOP at high powers

If you don't need the performance, climb at a higher speed.
 
All theory I've read (Nasa studies) says treat the Exit size as a cooling throttle. So that plus the tightness of the baffling primarily controls the CHT. Nosebowls not so much, but a poor design will not flow well.

I will echo and validate what Glenn and another Patrol Builder advised me... A bottom cowl that has some extra room at the exit tunnel for airflow out of the cowl had sufficient cooling with no lip. The Patrol was based in the south. I wish I had some dimensions. Lycoming wants a pressure differential of 5" of water across the cylinders. Measuring the pressure drop is pretty simple, tools are fairly inexpensive, and it seems that very few do it.

Glenn, what is the measurement of the opening between the top of the tunnel and the bottom cowl in your Four Place?

-----------------------------------------

Hi Brooke,

Missed this as I have not been looking much lately. The tunnel was made to the drawings. The drawings and airplane are a half hour away so someone may be able to give the numbers quicker.

The cowl at the tunnel follows the natural flat curve of what the firewall would be. The back edge overlap of the cowl is the same for the full perimeter of the firewall. The exhaust pipes are close to the sides of the exit and are never below the cowl line. It could be that the cowl overlap on the fire wall may have an eductor effect in that the air passes clean over the exit opening. The air going over the cowl at the exit could cause a low pressure to draw cooling air out. We concentrated on making the metal baffles fit tight to the engine and then seal the aluminum baffles to the cowl and nose bowl with the rubber gap seals. The rubber is tight and we have to be careful to tuck it in when we put the cowl nose bowl halves on.

Whee hit it on the head with the Continental engines. The Cont IO-360 has all the air intake and fuel injection systems on top of the engine. These systems are not hung under the engine to frustrate cooling air flow. The open air channel down the middle underside is impressive from the nose bowl to the exit. The taper of the underside of the cowl expands front to back so as the cooling air volume increases going back to the firewall there may be no pressure restrictions to the air passing through all the cylinders so the underside pressure may be uniform. The underside of the cowl tapers quick and is relatively flat with a very gentle curve across the under cowl. There is no air intake on the lower cowl to alter the air passing so it is a clean air flow down the cowl. My partner wanted to emulate the underside profile of the Mountain Goat aircraft as he thought the shape did a lot for take off lift. ( http://avstop.com/news/goat.html ). This is pure conjecture. It may be that our cowl has the large relatively flat for the air to accelerate down the length of the cowl to create a back draft or vacuum effect as it passes over the boot cowl opening. The under cowl air flow is at a down angle projecting away from the airplane so it could leave a low pressure in the boot cowl opening. We softened the boot cowl exit with the tear drop profile wrap on the firewall corners to aid laminar flow.

I read all the information I could find on cooling as well as the Bingelis books. It is not a science based design but more an instinctive design of using principles that would work with our cowl set up, to seal the engine top side to perfection, promote as much upper engine pressure possible, maintain as clear an exit channel down the underside as possible, have the exhaust tips with a slight elbow but not hanging in the air stream, and modify/fab the MC3A nose bowl for cooling to facilitate the steep under cowl angle. Cross fingers, collect lucky horse shoes and run it as we built it then modify the cowl if need be to add cooling. My partner wanted to supplement cooling but I wanted to hold off and not solve an issue where there may be none. So somewhere between the Continental engine and amazing luck the cooling all worked out. Have to win one once in a while.

Looking at Nev's photo that started this thread. His cowl looks so good up to the point that the cowl was cut out so that the air flow out of the cowl is interrupted and becomes inefficient. The altered cowl removes the cowl's ability to create negative pressure in the boot cowl outlet. The lip further frustrates exit air . Nev's exhaust goes straight back to look very good to me as it leaves a lot of boot cowl open. It may be that if the lower cowl overlapped the boot cowl the same as the rest of the cowl that the engine may be close to efficient cooling. Could possibly even put a slight extension on the lower cowl over the boot cowl to artificially expand the opening area and create more eductor or vacuum effect without affecting overall aerodynamics. It is all dependent on the engine characteristics, how well Nev's upper engine is sealed and the attention to laminar flow and clean flow in the cowl including the firewall.
 
Last edited:
Looking at Nev's photo that started this thread. His cowl looks so good up to the point that the cowl was cut out so that the air flow out of the cowl is interrupted and becomes inefficient. The altered cowl removes the cowl's ability to create negative pressure in the boot cowl outlet. The lip further frustrates exit air .

Very interesting Glenn. I plan to put nutplates along the lower cowl lip so I can attach different size outlets as required. I’ve got the tunnel sitting in place currently so I’ll get some photos later today and post here, I’m very interested in your ideas,
 
Here’s the lower cowl exit as it currently stands (a work in progress). The outlet area is approximately 120 sq/in.

If I left it like this and flew with it, what are the effects likely to be ?
How does the exit normally create a negative pressure area ? I understand how it is created by a lip, but I can’t understand how it is created in what would normally be a high pressure area under the aircraft.

Would I be better to run the cowling back to past the firewall, with a “bulge” below the exhausts to increase the outlet area rather than the current cutout ?

Thanks.

Click image for larger version  Name:	39702A66-C77E-4409-81E4-302A8B5918EA.jpeg Views:	0 Size:	238.7 KB ID:	66005
 
Hi Nev.

I am not deep into the aerodynamics but it would seem that the air passing down the lower cowl would be drawn upwards to perhaps hit the firewall by tripping over the edge of the cooling opening. Our lower cowl overlaps the firewall opening so the air going down the underside would create a back draft or negative pressure. The intent was to create induced air flow out of the boot cowl with a clean cowl shape. Cowl flaps make the cooling outlet opening variable and they create a bigger negative pressure to assist the cooling. Another form of induced flow. Once the cowl flaps are retracted then the cowl is streamlined with a clean air flow. With the nut plates you have options. I saw where a builder installed a shallow 60's or 70's muscle car like scoop to increase the cooling exit area. The rear edge of the scoop was inline with the rest of the cowl and looked very slippery. There are examples of reversed scoops for aircraft cowl cooling. The reversed scoop up would increase the negative pressure behind the firewall opening to draw out cooling air. Could form a scoop out of aluminum. Alternatively shape a piece of foam to make a streamlined reverse scoop then wax it and lay up fiberglass on it to form the final shape that you may like to try. There is also another aspect to our cooling in that the engine is a Continental IO-360 6 cylinder engine that is not generating the heat of a Lycoming 540 or a Continental 470.
 
Here’s the lower cowl exit as it currently stands (a work in progress). The outlet area is approximately 120 sq/in.

If I left it like this and flew with it, what are the effects likely to be ?
How does the exit normally create a negative pressure area ? I understand how it is created by a lip, but I can’t understand how it is created in what would normally be a high pressure area under the aircraft.

Would I be better to run the cowling back to past the firewall, with a “bulge” below the exhausts to increase the outlet area rather than the current cutout ?

Thanks.

The engine is still going to get some cooling. It's no different to flying with cowl flaps closed.
In fact, you would get about 50% more cooling than I have with cowl flaps shut.

That setup pictured should still provide adequate cooling to cruise lean of peak with a run-in engine.
You will have insufficient cooling to:
- operate rich of peak for extended periods
- break in a new engine
- climb at Vy for more than a couple of minutes
- cruise on very hot days

Of course it all depends how well your baffles are sealing, too. Any leakage, no matter how small, is unnecessary drag.

Without getting too deep into Bernoulli's principal and Newtonian laws.... Velocity of air outside the cowl is always higher than the velocity inside the cowl. The cowl outlet creates suction and pulls air through the cylinder cooling fins, combined with pressure above the cylinders forcing it through. The lip only enhances the effect.

Flying without a lip isn't going to result in air flowing up the firewall or anything like that.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Nev
You will have insufficient cooling to:
- operate rich of peak for extended periods
- break in a new engine
- climb at Vy for more than a couple of minutes
- cruise on very hot days

Thanks Jon. In your opinion do you think if I add a cooling lip to the current cutout, is it likely to then provide sufficient cooling to break in the engine? Any other suggestions?
 
Thanks Jon. In your opinion do you think if I add a cooling lip to the current cutout, is it likely to then provide sufficient cooling to break in the engine? Any other suggestions?

The community's experience shows that a lip is sufficient in most cases, to manage overheating issues. I haven't got personal experience with a lip.
As you have seen, many aircraft in hotter drier climates with the -540 engine have ended up installing additional ventilation because the lip was not sufficient on very hot days. There are many ways to do this, some more elegant than others.

Conversely, on very cold days, the lip and additional vents are all adding unnecessary drag, and the engine will run very cold with all that extra ventilation. Shock cooling is also a greater risk. Many ignore this issue, as overheating has more immediate consequences. Lycoming urges caution.

This from the Lycoming website: Operating in Cold Weather | Lycoming

Engine operating temperature is another item that is not usually given enough consideration in cold weather. We usually are very cautious about high oil temperature which we know is detrimental to good engine health, while a low oil temperature is easier to accept. The desired oil temperature range for Lycoming engines is from 165Ëš to 220Ëš F. If the aircraft has a winterization kit, it should be installed when operating in outside air temperatures (OAT) that are below the 40Ëš to 45Ëš F range. If no winterization kit is supplied and the engine is not equipped with a thermostatic bypass valve, it may be necessary to improvise a means of blocking off a portion of the airflow to the oil cooler. Keeping the oil temperature above the minimum recommended temperature is a factor in engine longevity. Low operating temperatures do not vaporize the moisture that collects in the oil as the engine breathes damp air for normal combustion. When minimum recommended oil temperatures are not maintained, oil should be changed more frequently than the normally recommended 50-hour change cycle. This is necessary in order to eliminate the moisture that collects and contaminates the oil.

And finally, power-off letdowns should be avoided. This is especially applicable to cold-weather operations when shock-cooling of the cylinder heads is likely. It is recommended that cylinder head temperature change not exceed 50Ëš F per minute. Plan ahead, reduce power gradually and maintain some power throughout the descent. Also keep the fuel/air mixture leaned out during the descent. If an exhaust gas temperature gauge is installed with a normally aspirated engine, keep it peaked to ensure the greatest possible engine heat for the power setting selected

We considered a variable oil cooler control to address these issues. I have heard others mention this before.
In the end, I felt that variable cowl flaps were more useful than a variable oil cooler inlet / outlet. Cowl flaps help manage shock cooling, CHTs in climb, and oil temp all at once. Blanking off the oil cooler only helps with one of these issues.
 
The Husky crowd has done some experimenting with the Cowl Exit lip. This thread shows they seem to like a "long exit ramp" shaped lip compared to the factory "Exit Dam" shaped lip. https://flyhusky.com/forum/index.php?threads/cowl-cooling-lip.2516/

I can visualize organized airflow over a ramp compared to a dam.....I'm thinking of Evel Knievel right now. (motor cycle stunt guy in the 1970's) Water flow in a river might be more applicable though.
 
I've now got 95 hours on the Bearhawk in mostly warmer ambient conditions. I've been able to control the CHT's through climb speeds and mixture when necessary, but I've decided to make a larger cooling lip and continue to use the current smaller one in winter. Here in the South Island of NZ the summer temps are typically in the mid 20°c and occasionally into the low 30's. Autumn and Spring tend to be in the teens, and winter is usually below 10°c down to -5c at sea level. Obviously it's a lot lower temps at altitude.

Yesterday I removed the small cooling lip (just 5 screws) to use it as a mould and decided to do a few circuits without it to see whether it was making much of a difference. It does. During the first circuit the CHT's started to climb and got higher with each circuit until after 4 circuits I had to land. At this point the Oil temp (normally a steady 75c) was peaking too, higher than I'd ever seen it. So I'm now sold on the benefits of the cooling lip. The new one will be slightly larger and will wrap around to give more overall area.

Here's where I'm at with it and I'll report back with results once it's finished. You can see the original orange one in the background of the top photo.

Click image for larger version  Name:	F9AE26FD-33BD-4471-9B7A-C6E472A42531.jpg Views:	0 Size:	3.01 MB ID:	74032

Click image for larger version  Name:	76E39C1B-B0A7-4EE8-831E-F3C2C67BB4AB.jpg Views:	0 Size:	3.54 MB ID:	74033
 
Last edited:
I managed to make a lip with .040 5052, 1" mounting surface, 1.25" lip 30 deg using a stretcher. 2" lip didn't work. I might try one more at 1.5 or 1.6 inch lip. It was pretty easy and quick to do and get it to conform.
 
I tried a bigger one, 1.7" lip. Worked very well. My first attempt at 2" was a fail. This was very easy to do, and I am no master metalworker. I just put a 30 deg bend, and then used a HF stretcher. lip.jpg
 
I've now got 150 hours on the aircraft, and simply left the new cooling exit lip (pictured above) on, even during the winter. I've found that so far I can get sufficient heat/cooling by varying the mixture. With the installation of a butterfly valve on the oil cooler I have been able to significantly restrict airflow through the oil cooler for winter ops. If anything, I will change the oil cooler winter setting to be even more restrictive.
 
Here's a photo of mine now - I ended up simply leaving the new larger cooling lip on during the winter and it's been fine. With the addition of an oil cooler butterfly valve (summer and winter setting) I'm able to vary engine temps sufficiently using mixture and airspeed.

Click image for larger version  Name:	0B8FED71-B807-441A-91DA-80D2149D5573.png Views:	0 Size:	2.91 MB ID:	77716
 
A discussion with Bob's engine guy Mike at Oshkosh indicated that a 3" lip at 30 degrees was about right. It seems people are putting on less of a lip?
 
I guess there's quite a few variables. Engine size is one, and outlet area has a large effect. Also on mine I'm ducting air from the number 6 cylinder to the oil cooler - so the CHT's tend to run hotter due to robbing the cooling air. I've got approximately 130 inches ² of outlet area underneath, plus another 10 inches ² above the battery etc.
 
We would have to ask Mike what he meant but it would be totally plausible to make the lip out of a 3" piece of material, with half protruding and half as an attachment flange.
 
One idea is to add nutplates so the cooling exit lip can be easily removed and resized during the test flying.
 
Back
Top