Bearhawk Aircraft Bearhawk Tailwheels LLC Eric Newton's Builder Manuals Bearhawk Plans Bearhawk Store

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

FWF Electrical & Ignition Wiring

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • FWF Electrical & Ignition Wiring

    Just curious if anyone has a diagram with AWG choices for their firewall forward electrical and ignition systems (not engine monitoring leads and misc)? The RV-10 FWF kit I purchased has included all but the electrical and ignition wiring details. I can and do reference AC 43.10 for wire gauge sizes based on usage, just curious what others are doing.

    For example, I've heard some say they use a 2 AWG from the + battery lead to the battery contactor. 2 AWG seems excessive. I've seen other references to 4 AWG for the same run. Seems like this should be standardized. Maybe it exists and I've missed it somewhere.

    Specifically looking for:

    - +Battery terminal to Battery Contactor
    - Battery Contactor to Starter Contactor
    - Starter Contactor to Starter
    - Battery Contactor to Alternator
    - Battery Contactor to Panel Bus Bar
    - Battery ground to airframe
    - Engine ground to airframe

    Thanks!

    (Forgot to mention... I have the Tony Bengelis books, Bob Knuckles Aeroelectric Connection, and several aircraft wiring books. Surprised there are no "basic" or "suggested" diagrams in those... EDIT: Diagrams DO exist in the back of Aeroelectric Connection )
    Last edited by robcaldwell; 10-06-2019, 01:50 PM.
    Rob Caldwell
    Lake Norman Airpark (14A), North Carolina
    EAA Chapter 309
    Model B Quick Build Kit Serial # 11B-24B / 25B
    YouTube Channel: http://bearhawklife.video
    1st Flight May 18, 2021

  • #2
    Rob,

    Having just finished that task.
    in the order of your list:
    2,2,4,6,10,2,4 AWG

    Some depends on length of run. I tried to keep voltage drop to starter negligible. That makes a huge difference in cold cranking. With respect to running a full electrical
    panel and ignition, my drop at the interior buss at the fuse panel
    is less than .2 VDC. With most system load On.

    At least it works in the garage.
    Looks correct under the cowl.

    KD #272

    Comment


    • #3
      What amperage alternator are you running and what are your maximum electrical amp loads?

      Comment


      • robcaldwell
        robcaldwell commented
        Editing a comment
        BC460-H 60amp (Main) & BC410-H 20 to 30amp (B/U). Still working on max amp load, but not expecting more than 30.

    • #4
      60 amp alternator.

      If all the loads were all on at once, worse case....
      52 Amps load.
      Normal approx 35 Amps.

      KD #272

      Comment


      • #5
        If you haven't already, I would suggest you read the Aeroelectric Connection by Bob Nuckolls. It has about everything you would need to know about airplane wiring including lots of discussion about wire sizes. You can download the book aec_12a.pdf which has 18 chapters plus an appendix with various power distribution wiring diagrams. We used number 4 wires from battery through contactor to starter. Works good.

        Comment


        • robcaldwell
          robcaldwell commented
          Editing a comment
          I am in the process of reading Bob Knuckles book, Aeroelectric Connection, but have not reached the appendix section with wiring diagrams. Looks like the "Z12 Dual Alternator, Single Battery" diagram will suit my desired outcome. Thanks for pointing this out, Ed.

      • #6
        Bob Nuckolls book is a good one, a very boring read but solid information. I used it referencing the pertinent chapters when needed. We sized our wires according to AC 43.13. We used welding cable for our battery leads as suggested by Nuckolls. I'd need to double check but I'm pretty sure we used #6 for battery leads (dual batteries) and to the starter. From the master to the power buss we used #8 tefzel. The alternator lead is #8 tefzel (60A). Hmm, I need to double check those sizes.

        It ia always good to see how others did things. My suggestion is to size the wires yourself using appropriate references.
        Scratch Built 4-place Bearhawk. Continental IO-360, 88" C203 McCauley prop.

        Comment


        • #7
          AC43 is totally appropriate and in line with every other DC thing I have done. I think generally you want your grounds to be the same size as your power lead, including battery ground and engine ground.

          I have seen a few vehicles burn to the ground (or waterline) because the starter wire caught fire, including a friends jeep that I was sitting in as he cranked away at the starter. I would never cheat a wire size on a starter wire after that!
          Last edited by svyolo; 10-06-2019, 05:20 PM.

          Comment


          • #8
            I made up my oil lines,or 2 out of 3 yesterday. I almost ordered premade once from ACS, but they are a bit spendy. Then I thought what if one or two didn't work as designed? So I bought parts. Good thing. AN8 fittings are really bulky. Even straight ones extend out 3" before the hose starts. Luckily I just eat one or two fittings, instead of 1 or 2 120 dollar hoses.

            Comment


            • #9
              If you want to avoid magnetizing the frame (and yes you do), don't use it as a current carrying conductor. Especially larger currents, starting being the whopper. That's not to say don't ground the frame, do ground it, but also run appropriate size grounds directly to your loads.

              Comment


              • #10
                This is interesting. I haven't found one mention of tin coated copper wire. When I was working on my FWF wiring I consulted one of our electrical engineers (who I found out had worked a stint at Boeing) about wire sizes for starter and alternator. We discussed welding lead for started but he told me that if I went with the tin coated copper that I could reduce the wire size and weigh. Apparently when you go tin coated the standard wire AWG and current ratings go out the window. I wound up using #4 tin coated from battery to the starter approximately 9ft and #8 tin coated from alternator to battery (60A Alt) and #10 regular copper to my main bus bar and my avionics bus bar. Just food for thought for what it's worth.

                Comment


                • #11
                  This is the schematic that I will work from. Dual Alternator / One Battery. This comes from the the Aeroelectric Connection site. A little cumbersome to locate your desired plan through this file tree. Probably best to choose the schematic you need from the book, then get the digital version here: http://www.aeroelectric.com/PPS/Adob...itecture_Pdfs/
                  Attached Files
                  Rob Caldwell
                  Lake Norman Airpark (14A), North Carolina
                  EAA Chapter 309
                  Model B Quick Build Kit Serial # 11B-24B / 25B
                  YouTube Channel: http://bearhawklife.video
                  1st Flight May 18, 2021

                  Comment


                  • #12
                    I've become quite familiar with this book and you'll want to become familiar with the associated forum. The author is very active there. Go to:



                    Then go to "AeroElectric-List" You'll normally have good answers in 24 hours. (These guys are the Experimental Aircraft Electrical System Gurus.)
                    Brooks Cone
                    Southeast Michigan
                    Patrol #303, Kit build

                    Comment


                  • #13
                    Originally posted by marcusofcotton View Post
                    If you want to avoid magnetizing the frame (and yes you do), don't use it as a current carrying conductor. Especially larger currents, starting being the whopper. That's not to say don't ground the frame, do ground it, but also run appropriate size grounds directly to your loads.
                    It'll magnetize anyways just from the static build up from flying.

                    Every starter uses the engine... and therefore the frame as a ground.

                    Comment


                    • #14
                      Originally posted by Bearhwk272 View Post
                      Rob,

                      Having just finished that task.
                      in the order of your list:
                      2,2,4,6,10,2,4 AWG

                      Some depends on length of run. I tried to keep voltage drop to starter negligible. That makes a huge difference in cold cranking. With respect to running a full electrical
                      panel and ignition, my drop at the interior buss at the fuse panel
                      is less than .2 VDC. With most system load On.

                      At least it works in the garage.
                      Looks correct under the cowl.

                      KD #272
                      That looks plenty reasonable to me

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X